By allowing ads to appear on this site, you support the local businesses who, in turn, support great journalism.
Not every family looks like a Hallmark movie
Sometimes being thankful means accepting family for what it is - not what holiday commercials tell us it should be
Not everyone's Thanksgiving looks like a Hallmark movie

Every November, television commercials would have us believe Thanksgiving is this magical occasion when families gather around beautifully decorated tables, exchange meaningful glances and spend the afternoon laughing over pumpkin pie.

Apparently, these advertisers have never attended an actual family Thanksgiving.

In their version, everyone gets along. Nobody brings up politics or religion. Nobody makes an inappropriate comment. Nobody asks a question that makes the entire room suddenly fascinated with their mashed potatoes.

Half the family isn’t bent over the group message, complaining about the other half.

They’re kidding, right?

In real life, Grandma is probably exhausted, someone forgot the rolls and at least two people are silently calculating how soon they can leave without appearing rude. Two others are tasting blood from biting their tongues so hard.

Welcome to the holidays.

There’s an enormous amount of pressure this time of year to create the perfect family gathering.

We’re supposed to set aside our differences, embrace our relatives and celebrate the ties that bind us.

But what happens when those ties are about the only thing we have in common?

Here’s something we don’t talk about nearly enough: Not every family is close. Not every sibling relationship is a lifelong friendship. And not every extended family gathering is the heartwarming reunion we’ve been conditioned to expect.

Sometimes you grow up in the same house, raised by the same parents, and somehow become adults whose lives look absolutely nothing alike.

You develop different interests, different priorities, different values and entirely different ideas about what constitutes a good time.

You might share childhood memories, a few family photographs and some DNA, but struggle to find enough common ground to carry on a 10-minute conversation.

And then Thanksgiving arrives.

Suddenly, you’re expected to gather around a table and behave as though you spend every weekend together swapping recipes and sharing your deepest thoughts.

It’s a strange expectation when you really think about it.

We don’t expect people to maintain close friendships with everyone they knew in elementary school. We understand that friendships evolve, people change and sometimes relationships simply run their course.

But when those people happen to be relatives, we’re told the relationship should somehow be different.

Family is family, after all.

But what’s that even mean? And why does it sound more like a burden than a blessing?

There’s a particular kind of awkwardness that comes with sitting across from someone you’ve known your entire life but with whom you have nothing in common.

Then someone says something they shouldn’t (oh, your family doesn’t have a banned list of topics? Lucky you), and you suddenly wish you had a dog to take outside.

Again.

For the fourth time.

Everyone having fun yet?

Then you have the work disparity. The people who show up late are the same ones who refuse to move from their seats while a few others show up early, do all the cooking and all the cleanup.

Aren’t you so thankful?

Of course, social media doesn’t help.

Scroll through Facebook on Thanksgiving, and you’ll see an endless parade of matching outfits, elaborate tables and captions about how blessed everyone is to have such an incredible family.

Maybe they are.

Or maybe the photograph was taken three minutes before an argument broke out over something that happened in 1997.

We never really know what goes on behind someone else’s holiday pictures.

And that’s probably worth remembering before comparing our own families to the carefully edited versions we see online.

The truth is, families are complicated.

People make choices we don’t understand. They build lives that look nothing like ours. Sometimes relationships become strained because of disagreements, hurt feelings or years of simply drifting apart.

And sometimes there’s no dramatic falling-out at all.

You just don’t have much in common anymore.

That doesn’t necessarily mean there’s hatred or resentment. It doesn’t mean you wish anyone ill. It simply means that sharing grandparents, parents or a childhood address doesn’t guarantee a meaningful adult relationship.

And maybe that’s OK.

I think one of the hardest things about the holidays is the expectation that everyone should feel a certain way.

We’re supposed to be excited about every gathering, eager to reconnect with every relative and overcome years of differences simply because the calendar says it’s time to be thankful.

But gratitude isn’t the same thing as pretending.

You can be grateful for the family you came from while recognizing that the family you’ve built is where you feel most at home.

You can wish your relatives well without needing to be deeply involved in their lives.

You can love someone without particularly enjoying spending an entire day together.

And you can choose peace without making some grand announcement about cutting people out of your life.

Sometimes peace is simply accepting that certain relationships are what they are.

And not forcing them to be something they’re just not.

Now I’m not saying skip the holidays altogether, nor am I saying fly through that list of banned topics like it’s your job.

You can be polite, I mean it is family and it’s only one day … hopefully.

But kindness doesn’t require manufactured closeness. Respect doesn’t require agreement. And being thankful doesn’t mean everyone has to sit around the same table for every single holiday.

This Thanksgiving, I hope people give themselves permission to enjoy the holiday they actually have instead of mourning the picture-perfect version they think they’re supposed to create.

Maybe your gathering is big and boisterous. Maybe it’s small and quiet. Maybe it’s filled with relatives, or maybe it’s spent with the people you’ve chosen to call family.

Maybe everybody gets along beautifully.

If so, congratulations. Hallmark may be looking for extras.

For the rest of us, perhaps the goal shouldn’t be a flawless holiday or a miraculous family reunion.

Maybe it should simply be good food, a little laughter and the freedom to celebrate without pretending our lives are something they’re not.

After all, Thanksgiving isn’t a Hallmark movie.

And sometimes the happiest ending is going home.

Yvonda Freeman is a reporter for the Great Bend Tribune. She may be reached at yfreeman@gbtribune.com